Run Stay Interviews Now, Before Resignations Hit

Employee Retention

11.19.26.

Picture it: bonuses are paid, reviews are done, everyone is exhaling for the first time in weeks. Then, in the first quarter of the new year, your best person gives notice. Looking back, the warning signs were there. But nobody looked.

You can prevent this nightmare from playing out by conducting stay interviews. They’re an affordable retention tool (compared to hiring and training someone new) and right now is the best time to start.

Why Now, and Not in January

Timing is the strongest argument for stay interviews. Holiday reflection, bonus payouts, and Q4 job searches all converge in the coming weeks, and each one narrows your room to act.

The next few weeks are the last stretch in which you can still change the outcome. People tend to reflect on their careers over the holidays, and many of them have been waiting for bonuses to land before making a move. Candidates often start interviewing in Q4 precisely so they can resign right after payouts. Your best people are frequently already in conversations with recruiters.

A stay interview happens while you can still act. An exit interview only tells you what you missed.

The cost comparison is lopsided. A stay interview takes about 30 minutes. Replacing a top performer takes months of lost productivity, recruiting fees, and disruption for the rest of the team.

Stay Interview vs. Performance Review vs. Exit Interview

These three conversations are easy to blur together, but they do very different jobs. Only one of them looks forward.

  • Performance review: backward-looking. It evaluates the employee, and it rates people rather than listening to them.
  • Exit interview: backward-looking, and too late to act on.
  • Stay interview: forward-looking. It evaluates the job and the company, and it is the only one that gives you time to respond.

The goal of a stay interview is to listen. It is not to rate the employee, and it is not to negotiate.

Who to Talk To First

You will not get to everyone, so start where a departure would hurt most. That means your top performers, the holders of key or hard-to-replace skills, and the high-potential employees you are counting on for the future.

Make sure the list also includes the people who are quietly excellent and rarely complain. They are often the biggest flight risks, because no one is checking on them and they have never needed to raise their hand.

A realistic target is 5-10 conversations before the holidays. That is achievable in a few weeks, even for a busy leader.

The Question Bank

You do not need to ask everything. Pick a handful from each group and let the conversation breathe.

Engagement and motivation

These questions reveal what keeps someone energized, and what quietly wears them down.

  • What do you look forward to when you come to work?
  • What part of your job energizes you most? What drains you?
  • When did you last feel really proud of your work here?

Growth and career path

People rarely stay where they cannot see a next step. These questions bring that picture into view.

  • What skills do you want to build in the next 12 months?
  • Where do you see yourself in two years, and does that path exist here?
  • Is there a role or project you’d love to take on?

Manager and culture

Managers shape most of the day-to-day experience, so this group asks about support, recognition, and voice.

  • What could I (or your manager) do more or less of to support you?
  • How do you like to be recognized?
  • Do you feel your ideas are heard?

Compensation and flexibility

Keep this group short and open-ended. The aim is to hear concerns, not to negotiate.

  • Is there anything about your total package or schedule that makes you question staying?
  • What would make your work-life balance better?

The flight-risk questions

These are the most important ones, so don’t skip them.

  • If you were to leave, what would be the most likely reason?
  • Have you ever thought about leaving? What prompted it?
  • What would a competitor have to offer to tempt you?
  • If you could change one thing about this job, what would it be?

How to Run the Conversation

Format matters as much as the questions. Start by telling the employee that this is just a conversation, not a review. That one sentence sets the tone for everything that follows.

Choose a neutral setting, ideally outside the normal office or on a walk. A skip-level leader or HR may get more candor than a direct manager, so think about who is best placed to lead.

Once you are talking, listen more than you talk. Take notes, and don’t get defensive, even when the feedback stings. Finally, don’t make promises you can’t keep. A candid “I’ll look into that” is better than a commitment you can’t honor.

What to Do With the Answers

The conversation is only half the work. What you do afterwards decides whether people believe it was worth having.

Start by looking for patterns across conversations. Themes tend to cluster around pay, manager issues, workload, and stalled growth. Follow up within two weeks with at least one concrete action, even a small one.

Build quick wins into your year-end and Q1 plans. Development budgets, flexibility, title adjustments, and project assignments are all realistic places to start. Then revisit the conversation in six months, which shows it wasn’t a one-time gesture.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Most of these come down to timing and follow-through, and the same four come up again and again.

The first is waiting until after reviews or bonuses, when the decision may already be made. The second is treating the stay interview as a disguised performance conversation. If it feels like a review, you will get review-style answers.

The third, and the most damaging, is asking and then doing nothing. That is worse than not asking at all. The fourth is only talking to people you already worry about, when your quiet high performers need the conversation too.

Let’s Talk

Every organization’s retention picture is different. If you are weighing how to start, which roles to prioritize, or what you are hearing from the market about pay and flexibility, we’d be glad to compare notes. Reach out to our team, or tell us what has worked for you. Call 715-845-5569 or email westaf@westphalstaffing.com today!

Professional Staffing & Recruitment Company

AboutWestphal Staffing

Westphal Staffing is dedicated to building connections between talent and collaborating with our clients. At Westphal, we have redefined the professional recruitment search experience. Learn more about our commitment to connect local candidates with Wisconsin employers.

Continue Reading

Help Your Team Refocus Without Adding to the Pressure

Every year around this time, something predictable happens: the energy that carried your team through summer starts to fade, and the pressure of Q4 deadlines starts

How to Identify Skill Gaps & Close Them

The beginning of every year comes with new goals, new initiatives, and new expectations for growth. But one question consistently shows up in conversations with executives

Prevent Holiday Burnout: A Guide for HR Leaders and Business Owners

The holiday season is a joyful time—yet it’s also one of the most demanding. Your employees are juggling work, family obligations, seasonal events, year-end deadlines, and