Stop Hoping for a Raise. Start Building the Case.

Career Growth

11.19.26.

The people who advance in their careers aren’t luckier or louder. They’re better prepared. Your review is a negotiation disguised as a conversation. The good news is that you can prepare for this negotiation in about a week.

Don’t worry, we have your back! We’ll walk you through how to build a wins document, gather metrics and feedback, benchmark your pay, decide what you’re going to ask for, and even practice the conversation.

Let’s start with one of the most important adjustments you can make. Your mindset.

1. Shift Your Mindset

Your review isn’t just a verdict on your performance. It’s a chance to have an open discussion and present your case. You probably know from previous reviews, managers rarely remember the full year, recent events dominate, and quiet contributions get lost. That’s why preparation is so important! It turns nerves into confidence because you’re working from evidence, not feelings.

Reframe the meeting: you’re not asking your manager to like you enough to give you a raise, you’re documenting the value you delivered to the company.

2. Build Your Wins Document

A wins document is a running record of accomplishments, ideally kept all year, though you can reconstruct it in an afternoon. Point readers to where the evidence hides: calendar, sent email, project folders, chat threads, past one-on-one notes, and shipped work.

For each win, capture four things:

  1. The problem or goal
  2. What you did
  3. The result (with a number if possible)
  4. Who benefited

Encourage readers to include the “small” stuff too, like process improvements, mentoring, covering a vacancy, retaining a difficult client, and work beyond their job description. Suggest a one-page summary of the top 5-7 wins, backed by a longer log. Close with the line: if it isn’t written down, it didn’t happen, at least not in your manager’s memory.

3. Collect Metrics That Matter

Metrics help you translate the work you completed into business language for your manager. You’ll want to focus on:

  • Revenue generated or protected
  • Time or money saved
  • Error rates reduced
  • Customer satisfaction
  • Speed to delivery
  • Team growth

Include project examples and copies of emails or messages that support your metrics.

We understand that some work is easier to measure than others. Here are ways you can “measure” your contribution if you don’t have metrics to back you up:

  • Before-and-after comparisons
  • Volume handled
  • Turnaround time reduction
  • Scope growth

Tip: ask a colleague or finance partner to help validate figures if you’re struggling to put your contributions into metrics.

4. Gather Feedback

Third-party praise carries weight your own claims can’t. This is where documenting all year comes in handy, but it’s ok if you’re starting from scratch. Look for client, peer, and leader emails and messages, project retrospectives, past review comments from the year.

If you’re having a hard time finding those messages, you can request feedback right now.  Send a short, specific request to 2-4 trusted colleagues, such as “What’s one thing I contributed this year that made a difference?”

Tip: You can also bring up last year’s feedback and prove your growth by what you did about it.

5. Benchmark Your Pay

Asking without data weakens your position, and so does guessing. Sources to use include recruitment firm salary guides, job postings with posted ranges (especially in states with pay transparency laws), industry and association surveys, and compensation sites.

Ensure you’re comparing apples to apples before making your request. Doublecheck the title, experience, industry, company size, geography or remote policy. Plus, look at total compensation, not just base. This includes bonus, equity, benefits, retirement match, flexibility, and PTO.

Tip: If you’re looking for a recruitment firm to trust, Westphal Staffing can help you! Call 715-845-5569  or email westaf@westphalstaffing.com

6. Decide What to Ask For

It’s important to have a few numbers in mind before you walk into your meeting. Have a primary ask, but with backups. Think through these options:

  • A raise (best supported by benchmark data and quantified results)
  • A title change (best when scope already exceeds the role)
  • A development budget (courses, certifications, conferences, coaching)
  • Other options like flexibility, a stretch project, a mentor or sponsor, or a promotion timeline

7. Plan and Practice the Conversation

At this point, we should start thinking about how the conversation is going to go when you walk into the meeting room. Here’s a simple meeting structure that you can practice:

  1. Open with appreciation
  2. Present your wins
  3. Share market data
  4. Make the ask, then pause and listen.

Next, it’s time to practice your follow-up questions to unfavorable responses from your manager. It’s helpful if you can rehearse out loud to get your full body prepared for this meeting, especially practicing your responses to unfavorable responses.

  • Manger Response: “There’s no budget right now”
  • Your follow-up question: “Is there a timeline for when there will be available budget and a non-cash alternative for this year?”
  • Manger Response: “Let me think about it”
  • Your follow-up question: “Thank you. When you can follow up?”
  • Manger Response: “You’re not ready, yet.”
  • Your follow-up question: “What specific milestones would change that? Is there training I can take to help me get there?”

Remember to calm your nerves by arriving early, taking steady breaths, and remembering this is not an unexpected conversation. Your manager is likely having a conversation just like this with their manager!

8. After the Review

The hard part is done! Next, make sure you follow up in writing within 24 hours, summarizing what was discussed and what you agreed upon. Set check-in dates and get commitments documented.

You don’t have to figure this out alone.

Whether your review is next week or next quarter, the work you put in now will pay off. But sometimes, even with a great case and a strong conversation, the best next step for your career is somewhere new.

If you’re curious about what else is out there, we can talk through your goals, share what we’re seeing in the market, and connect you with employers who are looking for someone with your skills and track record. Call 715-845-5569  or email westaf@westphalstaffing.com today!

Professional Staffing & Recruitment Company

AboutWestphal Staffing

Westphal Staffing is dedicated to building connections between talent and collaborating with our clients. At Westphal, we have redefined the professional recruitment search experience. Learn more about our commitment to connect local candidates with Wisconsin employers.

Continue Reading

08.19.26

Getting Serious About Goals Without Burning Out

Vacations end. Kids go back to school. The evenings get a little shorter. And somewhere in the middle of all that, the goals you set back

Did You Ghost Yourself Out of a Job?

We live in an age of instant communication. You can send a message to someone on the other side of the world and have a response

Build a Team That Never Lets Things Fall Through the Cracks

Talent isn’t always the problem. Most teams are made of smart people with good intentions and enough tools to efficiently serve in their roles. But projects